CBSE Class 11 English Hornbill — Exercise Solutions
Prose Chapter 1 — The Portrait of a Lady (Khushwant Singh)
About the Text
Khushwant Singh narrates his relationship with his grandmother through three phases: childhood (village), city school, and separation. The essay is a tribute to a simple, devout old woman.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. The grandmother was a religious woman. How is this shown in the text?
Answer
The grandmother's deep religiosity is shown throughout the essay:
- She spent her time in the village moving her lips in silent prayer, telling beads of her rosary.
- She always went to the temple in the morning, reading scriptures aloud.
- When she could not follow the narrator's education in the city, she spent all day in the temple.
- After the narrator left for university, she sat by the spinning wheel singing prayers almost continuously.
- Even in her final moments, she prayed and told beads — never breaking her routine.
Q2. Describe the changing relationship between the narrator and his grandmother.
Answer
The relationship went through three phases:
Phase 1 — Childhood (village): They were inseparable. She woke him, prepared him for school, and walked him to the temple-school. Their bond was close and warm.
Phase 2 — City (school): The bond weakened. She disapproved of his English school — she felt it taught no religion or morals. She could not help with his homework. They were physically together but spiritually drifting apart.
Phase 3 — University (hostel): Complete separation. When he left for university, she accepted it as the final break. Their meetings became brief and formal. She channelled her love into feeding sparrows.
Conclusion: The essay beautifully captures how modernisation can create distance even between those who love each other deeply.
Q3. What were the grandmother's last moments like?
Answer
When the narrator returned from abroad after five years, the grandmother was overjoyed. She sang, played the drum, and celebrated with neighbours. That evening she fell ill with fever. Sensing the end, she calmly refused to talk, told her beads, and prayed through the night. In the morning she died peacefully — lips still moving in prayer. Death came without drama, as she had lived — quietly and devoutly.
Prose Chapter 2 — We're Not Afraid to Die (Gordon Cook and Alan East)
About the Text
A family sets out on a voyage to recreate Captain James Cook's circumnavigation. A massive storm in the Southern Ocean tests their courage and survival skills.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. What preparations did the narrator make before starting his voyage?
Answer
The narrator (Gordon Cook) spent 16 years preparing the 'Wavewalker' — a 23-metre, 30-tonne wooden-hulled boat. He trained as a professional crew member, took courses in navigation and seamanship, and stocked the vessel with survival equipment. He tested everything meticulously, determined to simulate Captain Cook's global voyage.
Q2. What happened during the storm on January 2nd? How did the narrator and his wife react?
Answer
On January 2, a massive storm struck:
- Waves 15 metres high battered the boat.
- A colossal wave knocked the narrator off the deck; he was swept overboard but managed to grab a rope.
- Mary (his wife) took the wheel and steered expertly through terrifying seas.
- The boat's deck boards were smashed, hull cracked, two holes appeared — water was entering rapidly.
The narrator re-boarded, badly injured. Despite pain, he worked the pumps and kept the boat afloat. Mary's calm and courageous steering was crucial to survival.
Q3. What was the role of Jonathan and Suzanne during the crisis?
Answer
Jonathan (7) and Suzanne (6) showed remarkable maturity:
- Jonathan had a serious head injury but never cried or complained.
- He wrote a note to comfort his father: "We are not afraid of dying if we can all be together, you and Mummy, Sue and I."
- Suzanne quietly revealed she had a cracked skull — but hadn't told anyone to avoid adding to the worry.
Their courage gave the title its meaning — and gave the narrator the emotional strength to keep fighting.
Prose Chapter 3 — Discovering Tut: the Saga Continues (A.R. Williams)
About the Text
Scientists conduct a CT scan of Tutankhamun's mummy to discover the cause of his death and understand the last Egyptian royal dynasty.
Key Facts
| Detail | Fact |
|---|
| Tutankhamun | Last pharaoh of a powerful dynasty; died ~1323 BCE aged 19 |
| Discovery | Howard Carter, 1922 — greatest archaeological find of the 20th century |
| CT scan | 2005 — 1,700 X-ray slices taken to reconstruct mummy in 3-D |
| Cause of death | Still debated — theories include murder, accident, disease |
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. Why was Tutankhamun's mummy considered mysterious?
Answer
Tutankhamun became mysterious because:
- He died very young (~19), with no clear reason recorded.
- He was the last of his dynasty — after him, the royal line ended.
- Howard Carter found the tomb sealed and intact with treasures — but also found the mummy damaged.
- Carter removed gold bands by cutting the mummy — causing damage before science could study it properly.
- The cause of death (murder? disease? accident?) remains unresolved despite modern CT scanning.
Poem 1 — A Photograph (Shirley Toulson)
About the Poem
The speaker looks at an old photograph of her mother as a young girl at the beach. The poem moves from past memory to present grief — a meditation on time and loss.
Stanza Summary
Stanza 1: Mother's childhood — a beach photograph; she is 12, carefree, flanked by two cousins. Stanza 2: Mother as adult laughs looking at the same photo — remembering happy beach holidays. Stanza 3: Now the speaker's mother is dead. Both the holiday and the mother's laughter belong to the past. The speaker is silent — grief is beyond words.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. What does the poem reveal about the themes of time and loss?
Answer
The poem traces three moments across time:
- Mother's childhood (carefree beach holiday).
- Mother as adult (looking back with laughter).
- Speaker's present (mother is gone; only the photograph remains).
The sea is permanent — "the sea appears unchanged." But human beings are transient. The photograph freezes a moment, but cannot stop time. Loss renders the speaker speechless — "Nothing to say at all." The poem suggests that while memory can preserve the past, it cannot prevent loss.
Poem 2 — The Voice of the Rain (Walt Whitman)
About the Poem
The poet asks the rain to identify itself. The rain answers — it is the "Poem of Earth." The poem uses an extended metaphor comparing rain's water cycle to a poet's creative cycle.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. Explain the extended metaphor of rain and poetry in the poem.
Answer
Rain says it rises from the earth as water vapour (a poem originates in the poet's imagination). It wanders, changes form (clouds), and then falls back on earth as rain — nourishing and cleansing (a poem goes out to readers, nourishes them, and returns to the poet's credit). Rain descends whether acknowledged or not. Similarly, a poem's value is independent of whether it is appreciated.
Poem 3 — The Laburnum Top (Ted Hughes)
About the Poem
A laburnum tree in September is silent and still — until a goldfinch arrives. The bird's arrival fills the tree with noise and activity; it feeds its young, then departs, and the tree is silent again.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. What is the significance of the goldfinch in the poem?
Answer
The goldfinch represents life, energy, and creativity. The laburnum tree is described as "silent, quite still" in autumn — dead-like. When the goldfinch arrives, the tree suddenly comes alive with "chirruping, and trembling." The bird's presence transforms the tree from lifeless to vibrant. When the bird departs, the tree returns to silence. The goldfinch is thus the life-force that animates the tree — a metaphor for how a single vital presence can transform stillness into energy.
Poem 4 — Childhood (Markus Natten)
About the Poem
The poet wonders when exactly he lost his childhood — the stage of innocence, belief, and wonder — as he grew into analytical adulthood.
Key Ideas
- Childhood lost when he realised adults don't practice what they preach.
- Childhood lost when he learned geography and found no heaven.
- Childhood lost when he began to think for himself — lost innocence of unquestioning belief.
- Childhood retreats to "an infant's face" — pure, uncorrupted.
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. When does the poet feel he lost his childhood? What is the significance of the last stanza?
Answer
The poet lost his childhood: 1. When he found the concept of hell/heaven was not real geography. 2. When he saw adults preach love but practise hypocrisy. 3. When he realised he had his own mind to think independently.
In the final stanza, he says childhood now lives in an infant's face — in the innocence and wonder of very young children who have not yet been corrupted by the complexities of the adult world. Childhood, once lost, can only be remembered, not recovered.
Prose Chapter 8 — Silk Road (Nick Middleton)
About the Text
Nick Middleton travels the ancient Silk Road in Tibet, passing through difficult mountain terrain, interacting with Tibetans, and encountering wild nature including a herd of kiang (wild asses).
Important Questions and Answers
Q1. Describe the landscape of Tibet as described in Silk Road.
Answer
Tibet's landscape is described as extreme and awe-inspiring:
- Vast, open, windswept high-altitude plateau.
- Mountains surrounding every direction — including Kailas (sacred to Hindus and Buddhists).
- No trees; sparse grass; dust and boulders.
- Extreme cold; the narrator encounters harsh storms.
- Wild animals: kiang (Tibetan wild ass), antelopes, wolves.
- Few human settlements; nomadic herders living in tents.
The landscape is both majestic and intimidating — beautiful but brutally inhospitable.
Exam Tips
- Short answer questions: 2–3 sentences with one textual reference.
- Long answer questions: 8–10 sentences; structure as point + explain + quote.
- Poetry: explain literary devices (metaphor, simile, personification) with examples from the poem.
- All poems have a central theme — identify it in first sentence of your answer.
- Character sketch questions: physical description + personality + one key incident.